top of page
Search

Coaching for high performers in financial services

3 hours ago
5 min read
Coaching High Performers in Financial Services

Coaching for high performers is a confidential partnership between a qualified coach and an employee who already delivers results above the standard of their role. The coach helps that person widen their influence, sharpen senior decisions and plan the next career step. The Henka Institute, an ICF-accredited leadership coaching organisation, offers this work through its leadership coaching programmes for financial services and professional services firms.



High performers and high potentials compared

A high performer delivers results in the current role, and a high potential shows the capacity to succeed in a larger one. The two labels often get used as if they mean the same thing, which leads to coaching that suits neither group well. The table below sets out the distinctions The Henka Institute uses when it scopes a coaching engagement.


Feature

High performer

High potential

Main strength

Delivers results in the current role

Shows capacity for a larger role

Time horizon

The current role

The next one or two roles

Coaching focus

Refining execution, influence and decisions

Preparing for a leadership transition

Typical inflection point

A new remit, a missed promotion or a plateau

Promotion to a first or larger leadership role

Common risk

Staying in a role they have outgrown

Moving up before leadership habits are in place


What high potentials find hardest

According to Mayo's analysis for HBR, high potentials named five consistent challenges: leading others, leading change, leadership style, leading at scale and delivering business results. Their sponsors named six development areas, which were strategic management, emotional intelligence, communication, leading at scale, leading others and relationship management. Two items appear on both lists, which gives a coach a clear starting point for a first conversation with a newly promoted leader.



How coaching differs for each group

Coaching for high performers sharpens how existing strengths are applied, and coaching for high potentials prepares a person for the step into leadership. A high performer might work on influencing senior stakeholders, making decisions with incomplete information or delegating work they have always done themselves. For a high potential, the work covers how to lead others, set direction and handle the first year in a bigger role.


The Henka Model offers a practical structure for both groups. Its five HenkaQs are HeadQ, HeartQ, HungerQ, HumanSpiritQ and HenkaQ. In a conversation with a high performer, HeadQ work involves suspending judgment and recognising cognitive biases in how the person makes decisions, and HungerQ work looks at purpose, passion and energy management. With a high potential, HeartQ work builds the trust, active listening and curiosity that leading others depends on, and HumanSpiritQ keeps personal values at the centre of the choices that come with a wider role. HenkaQ brings the other four together through curiosity, autonomy and openness to being influenced.



Signs a high performer has plateaued

A high performer has usually plateaued when results hold steady while curiosity, initiative and appetite for stretch work fade. The Henka Institute has observed three early signals in financial services settings. The first is a shift from proposing new ideas to maintaining existing processes. Another is a drop in the number of questions the person asks in senior meetings. The third is a growing preference for familiar clients and projects over unfamiliar ones.


Each signal can look like competence from the outside, which is why a conversation with a coach often surfaces it before a performance review does. A useful question for a manager or coach is what the person would want to learn over the next twelve months if no one were measuring the result. Answers vary, and the pause before answering often tells the coach where the energy has gone.



Setting goals tied to business outcomes

The Henka Institute links each development goal to a business outcome the organisation already measures, such as client retention, deal quality or the readiness of a successor. A goal with that anchor gives the manager, the coach and the employee the same definition of progress.


A relationship manager at an asset manager, for example, might set a goal to lead quarterly reviews with two senior client stakeholders. The coach then works on the preparation, the conversation and the follow-up, and the manager checks progress against client feedback.

Each goal should also carry a personal measure that the employee defines, such as the share of the week spent on work they find meaningful. That measure gives the coaching a purpose that extends past the scorecard.



The manager's role and the external coach

Managers and external coaches contribute different things to a high performer's development. The manager provides context, feedback tied to daily work and sponsorship for new opportunities. An external coach adds confidentiality and an outside perspective on questions the person may hesitate to raise internally.


Employers already fund much of this work. The 2025 ICF Global Coaching Study reports that more than half of coaching clients are employer-sponsored, and it also notes that 73 per cent of coaches say clients increasingly expect professional credentials. That makes a coach's credentials a fair question to ask when an organisation selects a provider.


Managers can build their own coaching skills through the seven-module Leader as Coach programme. Managers who also lead a group of colleagues can read how to coach a high-performing team in a separate guide on the topic.



Coaching high performers in financial services

Coaching high performers in financial services calls for three adjustments that The Henka Institute sees often in its client work. Roles carry measurable targets, so coaching goals need a link to numbers the person already tracks. Decisions face regulatory scrutiny, so coaching time on judgment and cognitive bias carries extra weight. Promotion paths often reward technical depth before leadership skill, so the move into a first leadership role is a common inflection point.


Rachel Treece, founder and CEO of The Henka Institute, holds the ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC) credential, along with CPCC and ACTC certifications and a Fellowship of the Chartered Institute of Marketing (FCIM). Her profile cites over two decades of experience spanning global financial services and leadership development, and she is the author of The Henka Effect.


Organisations planning a wider programme can read the leadership development roadmap to see how individual coaching connects to organisational goals.



FAQ


How do you coach a high performer?

Start by asking what the person wants from their next role, then link development goals to a business outcome the organisation measures. Coaching for high performers then focuses on influence, decision quality and energy, with progress reviewed against agreed measures. The Henka Institute structures these conversations with the Henka Model.


What is the difference between a high performer and a high potential?

A high performer delivers strong results in the current role, and a high potential shows capacity for a larger one. Mayo's HBR analysis focuses on high potentials and lists the leadership challenges they face. Coaching for the first group refines execution, and coaching for the second prepares a leadership transition.


Do high performers need coaching?

Yes, because strong results still leave development needs. The high potentials in Mayo's analysis named five specific leadership challenges, and their sponsors named six development areas. A coach gives a high performer a confidential place to work on those areas before they affect results.


What does a high performance coach do?

A high performance coach helps a capable employee widen their influence, sharpen decisions and plan the next career step. Clients increasingly expect professional credentials, according to the 2025 ICF Global Coaching Study, so checking a coach's credential is a sensible first step.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page